Comparative Effectiveness and Early Discontinuation of Jadelle versus PPIUCD in Multiparous Women
- Karachi Institue of Medical Sciences. CMH Malir
- Postgraduate trainee, Karachi Institue of Medical Sciences. CMH Malir
Abstract
Objective: To compare bleeding pattern changes, 3-month continuation, device expulsion and reasons for early discontinuation between Jadelle and PPIUCD among multiparous postpartum women at a tertiary care hospital, Karachi.
Methodology: A prospective preference-based (non-randomised) comparative study enrolled 100 multiparous postpartum women (50 per group) between 1st October 2025 to 30th December 2025. Jadelle was inserted within 48 hours of delivery in non-breastfeeding women and at 3 weeks or later in breastfeeding women. PPIUCD (CuT 380A) was inserted post placental, transcervically within 48 hours, or during caesarean section. Participants were followed up at 1, 2, and 3 months after insertion by using structured proformas.
Results: Jadelle users were younger (mean 32.2 vs. 34.8 years, p=0.001). Heavy/irregular bleeding at 1 month was more frequent with Jadelle (70% vs. 50%; p=0.10 after continuity correction) and the groups converged by 3 months (16% in each). Device expulsion occurred exclusively in PPIUCD (8/50, 16%; Fisher's exact p=0.006). Three-month continuation was 80% with Jadelle and 52% with PPIUCD (risk difference 28 percentage points, 95% CI 10 to 46; p=0.006). Menstrual irregularity was the sole reason for Jadelle discontinuation; PPIUCD discontinuation was driven by expulsion (16%), social pressure (16%), desire to conceive (4%), menstrual irregularity (8%) and pain (4%). No pregnancy was recorded in either group (0/100).
Conclusion: In this single-centre, preference-based cohort, Jadelle showed higher 3-month continuation (80% vs. 52%). Bleeding disturbance was the main reason for stopping Jadelle, and expulsion the main reason for stopping PPIUCD, especially in older, higher-parity women. Method-specific pre-insertion counselling is therefore important. The groups differed in age and were not randomised, follow-up was short and the study was not powered to establish contraceptive efficacy; larger studies with 12-month follow-up are needed.
Metrics
Full Text
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Nasreen Hassan Niazi, Uzma Afreen, Bushra Iftikhar, Syeda Amna Asim Kazmi, Urooj Malik, Farwa Saleem

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.